Appendix 9 · Practical Example

From a $2 Million Monthly Loss to a Successful Trade Sale

1. Executive Summary

A $25 million personal care manufacturer recorded a $2 million monthly loss while continuing to generate substantial revenue. Unreliable reporting, unprofitable contracts and disconnected operating decisions concealed the deterioration. Appointed Interim COO, Gary Newbury established financial control and led a coordinated recovery. Profitability returned within five months, followed by a trade sale at book value in month six.

2. Context and Need for Intervention

The manufacturer employed 225 people across contract filling, soap manufacturing and specialist cosmetics production.

Commercial and operating disciplines had deteriorated. Management accepted business without sufficiently understanding production costs. Purchasing increased inventory exposure, while weak production and material controls disrupted fulfilment.

Premature revenue recognition and accounting inconsistencies obscured the trading position. The parent company faced continuing losses or an estimated $10 million closure exposure.

Recovery required someone to establish why a busy operation was destroying value and exercise the authority to correct it.

3. Establishing Reality

Gary connected the accounts to commercial, production, purchasing and warehouse activity. Three weaknesses emerged:

Unreliable financial visibility: problematic invoicing and premature revenue recognition concealed losses.

Poor customer and product economics: contracts failed to reflect actual yields and production costs.

Disconnected decisions: purchasing, production and inventory practices created costs elsewhere in the business.

One cosmetics operation produced one acceptable lipstick for every 500 manufactured. Purchasing could order 10,000 components for a discount when only 1,000 were required. Production sequencing increased cleaning and changeovers, while weak premix identification disrupted material flow.

Daily profit and loss reporting, introduced within two weeks, began replacing explanations with dependable evidence.

A saving within one department can become a larger loss elsewhere when nobody owns the combined economic result.

4. Leadership and Decision Rights

Gary held Interim COO authority across operations, finance and commercial performance. He worked with the executive sponsor on the recovery direction and made managers accountable for correcting weaknesses.

Daily shopfloor meetings brought leadership, supervisors and employees together around actual problems. Inexpensive shrink-wrap provided a telling example: the purchasing saving was consumed by repeated breakages, extra labour and wasted material.

Gary engaged union representatives on revised working arrangements while preserving a management structure capable of supporting an ownership transfer.

5. Intervention and Operating Changes

Gary corrected revenue recognition, reconciled historical invoicing problems and challenged customer contracts against their actual economics. Daily reporting made profitability visible.

He revised batch sequencing to reduce cleaning and changeovers. Colour-coded premix controls identified preparation dates and exposed premature production. Stronger planning and revised working arrangements improved scheduled performance.

Purchasing was brought closer to demand. Excess materials were reviewed for customer-approved alternative uses, supplier returns or credits. Warehouse identification and location disciplines strengthened material control.

Critical processes were documented visually, reviewed with employees and checked in practice. Managers became responsible for addressing the weaknesses exposed through daily discussions.

As performance recovered, Gary supported the financial, operational and asset information needed for purchaser scrutiny.

6. Results and Transfer

The intervention delivered:

Profitability within five months, establishing a profitable trading position before sale.

Customer fulfilment of 97%, improved from 75% within three months.

Scheduled production performance of 95% against plan, improved from 70%.

Inventory reduction of $500,000, alongside more than $1 million in savings from commercial, product, purchasing and facility changes.

A trade sale at book value six months after Gary’s appointment, avoiding the estimated closure exposure.

Operational responsibility transferred to the purchaser. Gary subsequently completed the former owner’s outstanding financial reconciliations and final accounting schedules.

Client testimonial

“Gary brought a rare mix of precision and urgency to the table. Within weeks, we had clarity. Within months, we had a turnaround. His ability to rally the team, uncover what really mattered, and lead the execution at pace was extraordinary. The business didn’t just recover. It gained value before we moved it on.”

Board Director, former parent company

7. What This Practical Example Demonstrates

Gary connected financial evidence with the commercial and operating decisions creating losses, then exercised the authority to change them. Recovery also changed the owner’s strategic options.

Reliable performance begins with understanding how the business actually makes or loses money, then making decisions on that basis.

Intervention Pathway: Reliable Performance Recovery.Delivery Model: Gary-led implementation under Interim COO authority, followed by transfer to the purchaser.

Gary Newbury
Senior Interim Executive — Reliable Performance Recovery & Operating Model Transformation