Appendix 14 · Practical Example
From Inconsistent Parts Availability to Predictable Customer Service
1. Executive Summary
Replacement-parts customers received excellent service when inventory happened to be available and unpredictable delays when it was not. Gary Newbury established that the difficulties extended beyond SAP and warehouse execution. He designed a differentiated service model and assisted implementation of the supporting changes. Next-day fulfilment for in-stock products subsequently exceeded 90%.
2. Context and Need for Intervention
The manufacturer supported an extensive installed base of specialist vehicles, including equipment operating for decades. Its aftermarket range exceeded 18,000 parts, from frequently demanded components to obsolete items requiring specialist manufacture.
Goods could remain in receiving for four or five days before becoming available. Supplier arrivals were poorly scheduled, while sales, production and aftermarket operations pursued conflicting priorities.
SAP released orders as stock became available, without controlling fragmentation. One customer order generated 39 separate picking and shipping instructions yet remained incomplete. Service for in-stock products was below 50% by Day 3.
3. Establishing Reality
Gary examined customer requirements alongside product characteristics, inventory, manufacturing, systems and physical fulfilment.
Three weaknesses emerged:
An unreliable customer proposition: delivery depended on incidental stock availability rather than deliberate commitments.
Undifferentiated inventory policies: frequent, slow-moving and obsolete parts were not managed according to their distinct requirements.
Misaligned operating disciplines: purchasing, manufacturing, receiving and order logic did not consistently support fulfilment.
The 39-shipment order demonstrated how substantial activity could fail to satisfy the customer. Gary concluded that isolated system fixes would leave the business without a coherent service model.
Repeated expediting can make an unreliable service promise survivable without making it dependable.
4. Destination and Design Decisions
Gary established four product service categories: next day (in-stock), five days, 28 days and on request.
The categories applied to products, not customers. One order could contain parts with different commitments. On-request items might require specialist manufacture, new tooling or agreement over tooling costs; immediate availability was neither promised nor economically appropriate.
He also established a meaningful fulfilment measure: an order line succeeded only when its full quantity was dispatched within the applicable commitment. Shipping two units against an order for 100 did not constitute successful fulfilment.
5. Intervention and Operating Changes
Following agreement on the blueprint, Gary assisted the client team in implementing the changes.
Existing SAP capabilities were aligned with the service categories. Order release, replenishment and allocation rules reduced fragmented picking and premature partial shipments.
Existing vehicle service bays were repurposed as dedicated aftermarket inbound space. Supplier arrivals were scheduled against receiving capacity. Goods could then be checked, booked and made available on the day they arrived, sometimes before the delivery driver left.
Working patterns across receiving, putaway, picking and shipping were adjusted to connect inbound availability with outbound commitments.
These changes worked together. Better fulfilment performance depended on available stock, while faster receiving needed a dedicated team, a schedule and capacity to clear receipts the same day.
6. Results and Transfer
Before the intervention, service was below 50% by Day 3. Following implementation, Day 1 in-full fulfilment for the redesigned stocked-product arrangements consistently exceeded 90%.
The operation gained differentiated commitments, more appropriate inventory policies, disciplined order processing, faster receiving and coordinated warehouse activity.
Gary developed the blueprint and assisted implementation with the sponsor and client personnel, establishing arrangements for the permanent organization to manage.
Client testimonial
“Gary quickly moved the conversation from ‘the system’s broken’ to ‘here’s what excellence looks like and how we get there.’ We didn’t need a new system. We needed someone who could see the whole battlefield and act fast. That’s what we got.”
Head of Quality and Customer Service, executive sponsor
7. What This Practical Example Demonstrates
Gary moved the discussion from software frustration to the relationship between customer expectations, inventory economics and operating capability. The result was a deliberate service proposition supported by practical operating changes.
Occasional excellent service is not the same as reliable service. Reliability must be designed into the operating model.
Intervention Pathway: Operating Model Transformation.Delivery Model: Gary-led investigation and blueprint design, followed by assisted implementation supporting the client team.