Appendix 16 · Practical Example
When More Resources Become Part of the Problem
1. Executive Summary
A home delivery business faced declining service, excessive costs, an 80,000-plus order backlog and threatened industrial action. Management feared the seasonal peak would overwhelm its resources. As Interim COO, Gary Newbury corrected disconnected operating practices, increased delivery productivity by 60% and delivered savings exceeding $5 million. He also developed a Board-approved network blueprint projected to double annual operating profit.
2. Context and Need for Intervention
The business operated 300 vehicles with two-person delivery crews and employed more than 1,000 people overall. Crews delivered bulky products into homes, sometimes installing appliances, removing equipment and making collections.
Average productivity was 25 calls per vehicle. Crews struggled to meet the 92% successful-delivery threshold required for meaningful bonuses.
Industrial relations had deteriorated to formal strike warnings. Management initially anticipated a seasonal volume increase of 50%.
Following the previous operational leader’s departure, Gary assumed executive responsibility across operations, sales, HR and finance.
3. Establishing Reality
Gary investigated the complete order-to-delivery process, including accompanying crews on their rounds.
Three connected weaknesses emerged:
Disconnected execution: poor routing, late customer notifications and repeated handling made rounds unnecessarily difficult.
Resources compensating for inefficiency: extra crews and vehicles absorbed work created by weak coordination, while incentives penalized drivers for failures elsewhere.
An expensive network: large depots stored and repeatedly handled goods, imposing costs that daily operating improvements alone could not remove.
Drivers could reach unattended homes, leave notification cards and carry undelivered goods for the rest of the route. The apparent low landing rate/productivity problem originated well before the vehicle left the depot.
Extra resources can make an unreliable operation appear manageable while concealing how much capacity its weaknesses consume.
4. Leadership and Decision Rights
Gary introduced focused daily management meetings across planning, transport, customer service, warehousing and finance.
He challenged the assumption that crews simply needed to work harder. An experienced colleague handled direct union negotiations under his direction while Gary concentrated on substantive operating improvements.
As changes were implemented, rounds became achievable, bonus opportunities improved and workforce cooperation increased. The formal strike warning was withdrawn.
5. Intervention and Operating Changes
Recovering the operation. Gary rebuilt routing around geographic density, orders, vehicle capacity and achievable workloads.
Customer notifications were reorganized to prioritize morning deliveries, with additional calling capacity arranged for afternoon customers. Earlier follow-up identified unavailable households before crews made pointless journeys.
Exceptions were communicated and treated appropriately in bonus calculations. Collections were better sequenced, and loading was coordinated with confirmed requirements.
Commercial discipline strengthened, including a minimum threshold of 25,000 annual orders for new accounts. As productivity improved, temporary vehicles and crews were released. The actual seasonal uplift of 10% across a week was handled without the expected capacity crisis.
Designing the future network. Recovery did not remove the inherited architecture’s limitations.
Gary developed a blueprint consolidating three major depots into a purpose-designed distribution centre nearer the principal customer’s supply base. Pre-sorted loads would move overnight in demountable containers through 60 smaller depots for local delivery.
The design reduced storage, repeated handling and dependence on expensive facilities. The Board approved it for client implementation.
6. Results and Transfer
Operational recovery achieved:
Productivity: 25 to 40 calls per vehicle, a 60% improvement.
Service: first-time landing performance improved from 80% within ten days to 97% within three days.
Backlog and space: more than 80,000 orders cleared and over 500,000 square feet of storage capacity released.
Costs: operating savings exceeded $5 million.
Resources: headcount reduced from more than 1,000 to 843, releasing more than 150 FTEs and more than 50 temporary vehicles.
The separate blueprint projected annual operating profit increasing from $12 million to $24 million. The estimated $12 million investment supported a projected 12-month payback. Continuing network implementation remained client-led.
Client testimonial
“Gary brought leadership, energy, and deep logistics expertise at a critical moment. He transformed a failing business unit into a high-performing operation, raising service levels, increasing productivity, and restoring profitability. His ability to challenge the status quo and deliver results was exceptional.”
Executive Board Member, Operations, home delivery business
7. What This Practical Example Demonstrates
Gary recovered capacity by correcting the weaknesses consuming it. He then established why a recovered operation could still require a different network to achieve its future potential.
Recovery restores control within the existing operation. Transformation addresses the limitations that remain when that operation is working properly.
Intervention Pathway: RPR to OMT, with concurrent recovery and future network design.Delivery Model: Gary-led recovery and blueprint development under Interim COO authority; subsequent network implementation client-led.